Hi All,
I recently acquired this medal group, attributed to John J Crotty (thanks to a few other collector's for the ID).
I acquired these from a gentlemen who in turn purchased them at an estate sale. All of the medals were in a cigar box, mixed in with some WWII material (thinking the WWII items may have belonged to a relative of John Crotty).
I'm not as proficient with early muster rolls, however after some digging on Ancestry, I believe I may have a grouping that spans from 1900 through WWI.
Timeline is as follows:
> Born 1872 (possibly March 17th)
Service:
> March 14th, 1900 - First enlistment from Earl City, PA
> 1900-1903 - Service with Co E, 15th Infantry
> 1903-1909 - No service info - possible 2 additional enlistments?
> 1909-1912 - Service with Co M, 5th Infantry
> December 10th, 1909 - Issued China Relief Expedition Medal No. 934
I found a NY Abstract of WWI service, showing John J Crotty with a reenlistment in 1913. My reason for believing this is the same John J Crotty as the one above, are as follows:
On the register of enlistments from 1913, it gives the following details:
> John J Crotty, Born Oil City PA, Served Co M, 5th Infantry
The NY Abstract gives the following details:
> November 16, 1913 - Reenlistment (Start of this enlistment, matches up with the end of the previous enlistment with the 5th Inf)
> Born in Oil City, PA
> Age at enlistment in 1913 - 41, and 8/12 months, with would make is YOB 1872, matching previous records
> Height, eye and hair color also match his first enlistment
> Discharged April 10th, 1919, although it does mention a reenlistment
Died - November 8th, 1945 - Headstone lists NY (which matches all of the service above). Headstone refers to a rank of SGT, which is highly likely for a final rank, and his service in the QM Corps, which is also referred to on the NY Abstract.
All of the documents below.
That said, I believe all of the medals in the photo below would have been issued to Crotty. Feel free to chime in if you think I may be off on my assessment.
Thanks!